# Why current AI cannot be an author under copyright, according to one philosopher

A peer-reviewed paper argues that copyright treats an author as someone who can answer for a work. On that reading, current AI systems fall short, but people who steer AI closely may still qualify.

- Category: Safety & evaluation
- Readiness level: I (Lab only) on Science Underway's four-step scale, as proposed
- Published: 2026-11-16
- Editor: Stefan Perdal
- URL: https://scienceunderway.com/articles/why-current-ai-cannot-be-an-author-under-copyright-according-to-one-philosopher

## The study

AI and the Responsibility-Bearing Status of Authorship. DOI 10.1007/s13347-026-01235-w. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13347-026-01235-w

## At a glance

- What it shows: A philosopher argues that copyright law quietly treats an author as someone who can be held responsible for a work. Current AI systems have not been shown to meet that standard, so works made entirely by AI may have no author at all.
- What it does not show: It does not prove that AI lacks a mind or intentions, and it offers no measurable test for how much human input is enough. It is an argument from cases and law, with no data.
- Why it matters: Companies that publish AI-made text, images or code need to know what they can own. This paper explains where the legal line probably sits and why.

## What the study shows

This is a paper in legal philosophy by Caterina Moruzzi of the University of Edinburgh. It was published in Philosophy & Technology after peer review. It has no experiments or data. It is an argument built from court cases, statutes and earlier scholarship, with a focus on US law.

The author's starting point is that being an author is a status, not just a fact about who pressed the button. That status carries rights, such as credit and control over copies. It also carries duties, such as not plagiarising. So an author must be someone who can answer for the work.

She names three conditions that together make someone a fitting author. She calls them the ACE cluster. Intentional agency means the work comes from a purposeful aim. Guided control means the person steers how the work takes shape. Relational expression means the work states a position that others can attribute to the author and challenge.

The author argues that the familiar rule that authors must be human is a shortcut for these three capacities. It is not, on her reading, a bias about species. Current AI systems are excluded because they have not been shown to meet all three together, not because they are machines.

She tests this against known cases. In Thaler v. Perlmutter, a US appeals court refused copyright for an image listed as made solely by an AI system. In her reading, nobody met the three conditions, so the image had no author. In the Zarya of the Dawn comic, the US Copyright Office protected the human text and layout but not the raw images made with the Midjourney image generator.

She then weighs three legal options. Naming AI as an author is hard to justify. Treating human users as authors works when their control is substantial. Leaving fully automated output unowned, in the public domain, fits cases where no one meets the bar.

## Our reading

In our reading, the most useful move here is reframing the human-only rule. Critics call it prejudice against machines. The author recasts it as a test of responsibility: can someone be named, praised, blamed and asked why. That gives a firmer reason for current law than species alone, and it leaves the door open if AI systems ever meet the test.

The practical message for most organisations is about the middle ground. The author sets the bar for human authorship above one-click generation and below control of every detail. A designer who writes many prompts, picks among outputs, edits them and arranges them into a finished piece may well be the author. Someone who types one generic prompt and keeps the first result probably is not.

A concrete example: a marketing team uses an image generator for a campaign. If the team only selects a stock-style output, a competitor may be free to reuse it. If the team has detailed records of how it shaped, edited and combined the images, it has a much stronger claim to own the result.

The rest of the article (what it means, limits, what to watch) is free for members: https://scienceunderway.com/articles/why-current-ai-cannot-be-an-author-under-copyright-according-to-one-philosopher

## How this was made

An AI model read the study and wrote this article in the structure Science Underway uses. An editor reviewed it and approved it for publication. Check the original study before you rely on the details.

---
Source: Science Underway, https://scienceunderway.com/. Please link to the article when you cite it.
